Pakistan garment industry is one of the largest and oldest industries in the country. The industry is also one of the major sources of export earnings, employment generation, and value addition for the economy. However, the industry faces several challenges and threats in the global market, such as low productivity, high costs, poor quality, weak innovation, and fierce competition. To understand the competitive forces that shape the industry and determine its attractiveness and profitability, we can use the Five Forces analysis framework developed by Michael Porter.

The Five Forces analysis is a tool that helps to identify and evaluate the competitive pressures in a market or industry. The five forces are:

• Threat of new entrants: The possibility of new competitors entering the industry and eroding the market share and profitability of existing players.
• Bargaining power of suppliers: The ability of suppliers to influence the price, quality, and terms of supply of raw materials or inputs to the industry.
• Bargaining power of buyers: The ability of buyers to influence the price, quality, and terms of purchase of products or services from the industry.
• Threat of substitutes: The possibility of customers switching to alternative products or services that meet their needs in a similar or better way.
• Rivalry among existing competitors: The intensity of competition within the industry, which affects the price, quality, and innovation of products or services.

In this article, we will apply the Five Forces analysis to Pakistan’s garment industry and assess its strengths and weaknesses.

Threat of new entrants

The threat of new entrants in Pakistan’s garment industry is moderate to high. Some of the factors that affect the entry barriers are:

• Capital requirements: The garment industry requires a significant amount of capital investment to set up and operate a factory, buy machinery and equipment, hire labor, and comply with quality and safety standards. This can deter some potential entrants who lack financial resources or access to credit.
• Economies of scale: The garment industry benefits from economies of scale, which means that larger firms can produce at lower costs per unit than smaller firms. This can give an advantage to existing players who have established production facilities, distribution networks, and customer relationships over new entrants who have to start from scratch.
• Government policies: The government policies can either facilitate or hinder the entry of new players in the garment industry. For example, the government can provide incentives such as tax exemptions, duty drawbacks, cash subsidies, bonded warehouse facilities, and export processing zones to attract new entrants. On the other hand, the government can also impose regulations such as import tariffs, quotas, licenses, and standards that can increase the costs and risks of entry.
• Customer loyalty: The garment industry depends on customer loyalty, which is influenced by factors such as brand image, quality, design, price, and service. Existing players who have established a loyal customer base can enjoy a competitive edge over new entrants who have to build their reputation and trust in the market.

Based on these factors, we can conclude that the threat of new entrants in Pakistan’s garment industry is moderate to high, depending on the segment and product category. The industry is open to new entrants who can offer innovative, differentiated, and value-added products and services that can meet the changing needs and preferences of customers. However, new entrants also face significant challenges and barriers that can limit their success and survival in the industry.

Bargaining power of suppliers

The bargaining power of suppliers in Pakistan’s garment industry is low to moderate. Some of the factors that affect the supplier power are:

• Number and concentration of suppliers: The garment industry relies on various types of suppliers, such as cotton growers, yarn spinners, fabric weavers, dyeing and printing units, accessories makers, and logistics providers. The number and concentration of suppliers vary depending on the type and quality of inputs required. For example, Pakistan has a large number of cotton growers and yarn spinners who supply raw materials to the garment industry. However, Pakistan has a limited number of fabric weavers and dyeing and printing units who supply finished fabrics to the garment industry. This means that the supplier power is lower for raw materials than for finished fabrics.
• Availability of substitutes: The availability of substitutes for the inputs used by the garment industry affects the supplier power. For example, cotton is the main raw material used by the garment industry in Pakistan. However, cotton can be substituted by other natural or synthetic fibers, such as wool, silk, polyester, nylon, etc. This means that the supplier power of cotton growers is lower than that of other fiber producers.
• Switching costs: The switching costs refer to the costs and risks involved in changing from one supplier to another. The switching costs depend on factors such as contracts, quality standards, delivery times, and relationships. For example, if a garment manufacturer has a long-term contract with a fabric supplier who meets its quality standards and delivery times, it may be reluctant to switch to another supplier who offers lower prices but lower quality or reliability. This means that the supplier power is higher for those suppliers who have established contracts and relationships with their buyers.
• Importance of inputs: The importance of inputs refers to the degree to which the inputs affect the quality, performance, and differentiation of the final products. The importance of inputs varies depending on the type and category of products. For example, for basic and low-value-added products, such as t-shirts and jeans, the inputs may not be very important, as they are easily available and standardized. However, for high-end and high-value-added products, such as suits and dresses, the inputs may be very important, as they require specific and customized fabrics, colors, patterns, and accessories. This means that the supplier power is higher for those suppliers who provide important and unique inputs to their buyers.

Based on these factors, we can conclude that the bargaining power of suppliers in Pakistan’s garment industry is low to moderate, depending on the type and category of inputs. The industry has a large and diverse pool of suppliers who can provide various types of inputs at competitive prices. However, the industry also faces some challenges and constraints in terms of availability, quality, and innovation of inputs, especially for finished fabrics and accessories.

Bargaining power of buyers

The bargaining power of buyers in Pakistan’s garment industry is high. Some of the factors that affect the buyer power are:

• Number and concentration of buyers: The garment industry sells its products to various types of buyers, such as wholesalers, retailers, brands, and consumers. The number and concentration of buyers vary depending on the type and category of products. For example, for basic and low-value-added products, such as t-shirts and jeans, the industry has a large number of buyers who are dispersed and fragmented. However, for high-end and high-value-added products, such as suits and dresses, the industry has a small number of buyers who are concentrated and consolidated. This means that the buyer power is higher for high-end and high-value-added products than for basic and low-value-added products.
• Availability of substitutes: The availability of substitutes for the products offered by the garment industry affects the buyer power. For example, Pakistan’s garment industry faces intense competition from other countries that produce similar or better products at lower prices or higher quality. These countries include China, India, Bangladesh, Vietnam, Turkey, etc. This means that the buyer power is higher for those buyers who have access to alternative sources of supply from other countries.
• Switching costs: The switching costs refer to the costs and risks involved in changing from one seller to another. The switching costs depend on factors such as contracts, quality standards, delivery times, and relationships. For example, if a buyer has a long-term contract with a garment manufacturer who meets its quality standards and delivery times, it may be reluctant to switch to another manufacturer who offers lower prices but lower quality or reliability. This means that the buyer power is lower for those buyers who have established contracts and relationships with their sellers.
• Importance of products: The importance of products refers to the degree to which the products affect the quality, performance, and differentiation of the final products or services offered by the buyers. The importance of products varies depending on the type and category of buyers. For example, for wholesalers and retailers, the products may not be very important, as they are intermediaries who sell the products to other buyers. However, for brands and consumers, the products may be very important, as they are end-users who use the products for their own purposes. This means that the buyer power is higher for those buyers who value the products highly and have specific and customized preferences and expectations.

Based on these factors, we can conclude that the bargaining power of buyers in Pakistan’s garment industry is high. The industry faces a large and diverse pool of buyers who have high bargaining power and low loyalty. The buyers can easily switch to other sellers who offer better prices, quality, or variety of products. The buyers can also influence the price, quality, and terms of purchase of products from the industry.

Threat of substitutes

The threat of substitutes in Pakistan’s garment industry is high. Some of the factors that affect the substitution threat are:

• Availability of substitutes: The availability of substitutes refers to the degree to which there are alternative products or services that can meet the same or similar needs and wants of customers. The availability of substitutes depends on factors such as price, quality, availability, and accessibility. For example, Pakistan’s garment industry faces a high availability of substitutes from other countries that produce similar or better products at lower prices or higher quality. These countries include China, India, Bangladesh, Vietnam, Turkey, etc. These countries have a competitive edge over Pakistan in terms of cost, quality, innovation, and market access.
• Performance of substitutes: The performance of substitutes refers to the degree to which the alternative products or services can satisfy or exceed the expectations and preferences of customers. The performance of substitutes depends on factors such as features, benefits, attributes, and design. For example, Pakistan’s garment industry faces a high performance of substitutes from other countries that produce more fashionable, functional, and sustainable products than Pakistan. These countries have a competitive edge over Pakistan in terms of design, technology, and social responsibility.
• Switching costs: The switching costs refer to the costs and risks involved in changing from one product or service to another. The switching costs depend on factors such as contracts, quality standards, delivery times, and relationships. For example, if a customer has a long-term contract with a garment seller who meets its quality standards and delivery times, it may be reluctant to switch to another seller who offers lower prices but lower quality or reliability. This means that the substitution threat is lower for those customers who have established contracts and relationships with their sellers.

Rivalry among existing competitors

The rivalry among existing competitors in Pakistan’s garment industry is high. Some of the factors that affect the competitive rivalry are:

• Number and concentration of competitors: The number and concentration of competitors refer to the degree to which the market or industry is fragmented or consolidated. The number and concentration of competitors depend on factors such as market size, growth, entry barriers, exit barriers, and differentiation. For example, Pakistan’s garment industry has a large number of competitors who are dispersed and fragmented. The industry has a low market size and growth, low entry barriers, high exit barriers, and low differentiation. This means that the competitive rivalry is high for the industry, as the competitors have to compete for a limited market share and profitability.
• Diversity of competitors: The diversity of competitors refers to the degree to which the competitors have different strategies, objectives, resources, and capabilities. The diversity of competitors depends on factors such as ownership, origin, size, scope, and focus. For example, Pakistan’s garment industry has a high diversity of competitors who have different ownership structures (public, private, cooperative), origins (local, foreign), sizes (small, medium, large), scopes (vertical, horizontal), and focuses (basic, value-added). This means that the competitive rivalry is high for the industry, as the competitors have to deal with different types of threats and opportunities from each other.
• Degree of differentiation: The degree of differentiation refers to the degree to which the products or services offered by the competitors are similar or different in terms of features, benefits, attributes, and design. The degree of differentiation depends on factors such as innovation, quality, design, branding, and marketing. For example, Pakistan’s garment industry has a low degree of differentiation among its products or services. The industry mainly produces basic and low-value-added products that are easily available and standardized. This means that the competitive rivalry is high for the industry, as the competitors have to compete mainly on price rather than on quality or variety.

Based on these factors, we can conclude that the rivalry among existing competitors in Pakistan’s garment industry is high. The industry has a large and diverse pool of competitors who have to fight for a limited and stagnant market share and profitability. The industry also has a low degree of differentiation among its products or services that makes it difficult to create loyal customers and sustainable competitive advantage.

Conclusion

Pakistan’s garment industry is one of the largest and oldest industries in the country that has a significant impact on the economy and society. However, the industry faces several challenges and threats in the global market that affect its attractiveness and profitability.

To understand these challenges and threats better, we can use the Five Forces analysis framework to analyze the competitive forces that shape the industry. The Five Forces analysis shows that the industry faces a high threat of new entrants, a high bargaining power of buyers, a high threat of substitutes, and a high rivalry among existing competitors. The industry also faces a low to moderate bargaining power of suppliers, depending on the type and category of inputs.

Based on this analysis, we can say that Pakistan’s garment industry is not very attractive or profitable in the current scenario. The industry needs to overcome its weaknesses and leverage its strengths to cope with the competitive pressures and create value for its stakeholders. The industry needs to improve its productivity, quality, innovation, and differentiation to offer better products and services to its customers. The industry also needs to diversify its export markets, products, and sources of supply to reduce its dependence and vulnerability to external factors.

If you found this article helpful, please share it with your friends and colleagues who might benefit from it.